In evaluating the collection, I would assign an average rating of 4.14 stars, which reflects my personal enjoyment of the individual stories contained within. As one might anticipate in an anthology of this nature, there are stories that shine brightly, others that falter, and a range of narratives that occupy the middle ground. With a total of twenty-nine stories of varying lengths and themes, readers are likely to find selections that resonate with their tastes. However, if you’re specifically seeking something frightening or suspenseful, I must advise against this book, as I found none of the tales genuinely eerie or terrifying. Though it features an ensemble of killers and a certain atmospheric quality, it lacks the spine-chilling thrills that typically accompany horror stories. The only thing that might send shivers down your spine would be the idea of encountering a man in a red suit during the dark of night.

Among the 29 stories, I discovered four that truly captivated me while the remainder fell into the category of mediocre.

One standout is “Tommy’s Christmas” by John R. Little, which presents a compelling twist on the holiday theme. The narrative follows a burglar disguised as Santa Claus who mistakenly invades the wrong home on what is supposed to be a joyous occasion. While the story doesn’t delve into the realm of horror, the clever twist at the end offers a satisfying surprise that elevates the overall experience.

Another noteworthy entry is “The Christmas Spirit” by Lisa Morton. This story explores the unraveling marriage of a couple who, in an effort to rekindle their connection, escape to the rustic country home of an aunt. Upon their arrival, they come across an old book that provides enjoyable entertainment until the plot thickens and complications arise. The story weaves a subtle gothic atmosphere throughout, effectively enhancing the emotional depth and tension as the couple’s adventure unfolds.

These stories, while not overtly scary, each offer unique elements that enrich the anthology, making them stand out among their peers.

‘Psychopathic Remix’ by J.C. Michael I found to be the most fun and macabre thing in this anthology. The Twelve Days of Christmas with a killer twist. I sang instead of just reading it and it was fun.

‘Deck The Halls by Xtina Marie is a nice poem that I liked and think that everyone else will too.

I found the above to be the most creative out the bunch though there were others that were good in their own way.

My rating: ☆☆☆☆